If you are looking for a great mom and pop place for Italian food in the Columbus, Ohio area, look no further than Carfagna’s Kitchen . This place offers great Italian food with a different kind of dining experience. If you are looking for a Columbus, Ohio restaurant that won’t disappoint, Carfagna’s Kitchen is the one to visit.
The restaurant is located at 2025 Polaris Parkway in Columbus just down the road from the Polaris Fashion Place and is open Monday through Saturday. The first thing that you will notice is that you are assigned a table number to be seated at. Menus are at each table for your convenience and to order you must go up to the counter. If the place is busy, they encourage you to wait on ordering until you have been assigned a table. The prices are a little high, but most of the food is homemade and gratuity is built into the price since there is a no tipping policy. Food is brought out to you by one of the servers and if you need anything during your meal, just catch one of them as they go by.
This is some of the best Italian food in Columbus. My kids gobbled up the fettuccine alfredo in a matter of minutes and I think it was the first time my seven year old managed to finish a meal before me. This was in between bites of saying how it was the best fettuccine ever. The spaghetti and meatballs was a plentiful portion and comes with salad and garlic bread. The sauce is wonderful and is the closest I have ever tasted to the sauce my Italian grandmother used to make. The portion sizes of the meals are large and you will have a hard time leaving enough room for dessert. If you decide to order dessert, you can go up to the display case and pick from choices such as handmade cannolis, tiramisu, and other Italian oriented desserts.
If you are looking for a place for Italian food in Columbus, Ohio, you will want to check out Carfagna’s Kitchen in the Polaris area. It’s a unique dining experience that will please the entire family, even if you have picky eaters. You will get a decent sized portion of some Italian comfort food and won’t even have to worry about leaving a tip behind.