After 10 seasons, we have had 61 fabulous females grace the American Idol stage. Who will make the top 10, and who will unfortunately come in last?
Fans have avidly watched 10 seasons of American Idol and have never been shy about who their favorite contestants are. Some of the female contestants have gained world wide fame, such as Kelly Clarkson, Jennifer Hudson, and Carrie Underwood. Others have fallen into obscurity, such as Nikki McKibbin and Julia DeMato. Regardless, there is a place in our hearts for each and every one of them!
I will rate each of our fabulous females on Tone, Technique, Range, and Performance. They will have the opportunity to get 10 points for each, with a perfect score being 40 out of 40. Let’s see how all the girls rank! If there is a tie, the female most successful post Idol or with the most consistency will win.
61. Ryan Starr: Tone-5/10 Technique-2/10 Range-4/10 Performance-7/10 18/40
60. Nikki McKibbin: Tone-6/10 Technique- 1/10 Range- 5/10 Performance-6/10 18/40
59. Paige Miles: Tone-6/10 Technique-3/10 Range-5/10 Performance- 4/10 18/40
58. Carmen Rasmusen: Tone-4/10 Technique- 3/10 Range- 5/10 Performance- 7/10 19/40
57. Lacey Brown: Tone-5/10 Technique- 5/10 Range-4/10 Performance-6/10 20/40
56. Julia DeMato: Tone-5/10 Technique-5/10 Range- 6/10 Performance- 4/10 20/40
55. Megan Joy: Tone-6/10 Technique-4/10 Range- 5/10 Performance-5/10 20/40
54. Kristy Lee Cook: Tone-5/10 Technique-4/10 Range-5/10 Performance- 6/10 20/40
53. Lindsey Cardinale: Tone-7/10 Technique-5/10 Range-4/10 Performance-5/10 21/40
52. Melissa McGhee: Tone-6/10 Technique-5/10 Range-6/10 Performance-4/10 21/40
51. Camile Velasco: Tone-6/10 Technique-5/10 Range-6/10 Performance-4/10 21/40
50. Leah LaBelle: Tone- 6/10 Technique-6/10 Range-6/10 Performance-4/10 22/40
49. Jasmine Trias: Tone-6/10 Technique- 5/10 Range-5/10 Performance-6/10 22/40
48. Kellie Pickler: Tone-6/10 Technique-4/10 Range-6/10 Performance- 6/10 22/40
47. Lil Rounds: Tone-6/10 Technique-4/10 Range-6/10 Performance-7/10 23/40
46. Mikalah Gordon: Tone-6/10 Technique-5/10 Range-6/10 Performance-6/10 23/40
45.Thia Megia: Tone-8/10 Technique-6/10 Range-5/10 Performance-4/10 23/40
44. Amy Adams: Tone-5/10 Technique-7/10 Range-5/10 Performance- 6/10 23/40
43. Lauren Alaina: Tone-6/10 Technique-5/10 Range-6/10 Performance-6/10 23/40
42. Brooke White: Tone-7/10 Technique-5/10 Range-5/10 Performance-6/10 23/40
41. Katie Stevens: Tone-5/10 Technique-6/10 Range-6/10 Performance-7/10 24/40
40. Haley Scarnato: Tone-5/10 Technique-5/10 Range-6/10 Performance- 8/10 24/40
39. Amanda Overmyer: Tone-9/10 Technique- 4/10 Range-5/10 Performance-7/10 25/40
38. Jessica Sierra: Tone-7/10 Technique-5/10 Range-7/10 Performance-6/10 25/40
37. Ramiele Malubay: Tone-7/10 Technique-6/10 Range-6/10 Performance-6/10 25/40
36. Christina Christian: Tone-6/10 Technique-5/10 Range-6/10 Performance-8/10 25/40
35. Lisa Tucker: Tone-6/10 Technique-7/10 Range-7/10 Performance-6/10 26/40
34. Ashton Jones: Tone-6/10 Technique-6/10 Range-8/10 Performance-6/10 26/40
33. Naima Adedapo: Tone-7/10 Technique-5/10 Range-6/10 Performance-8/10 26/40
32. Jasmine Murray: Tone-7/10 Technique-7/10 Range-8/10 Performance-5/10 27/40
31. Kimberly Caldwell: Tone-10/10 Technique-4/10 Range-5/10 Performance-9/10 28/40
30. Mandisa: Tone-6/10 Technique-6/10 Range-8/10 Performance- 8/10 28/40
29. Gina Glocksen: Tone-7/10 Technique-7/10 Range- 6/10 Performance- 8/10 28/40
28. Karen Rodriguez: Tone-7/10 Technique-7/10 Range-7/10 Performance- 7/10 28/40
27. Stephanie Edwards: Tone-6/10 Technique-7/10 Range- 8/10 Performance-7/10 28/40
26. Siobhan Magnus: Tone-7/10 Technique-6/10 Range-8/10 Performance-8/10 29/40
25. Vanessa Olivarez: Tone-6/10 Technique-7/10 Range-7/10 Performance-8/10 29/40
24. Didi Benami: Tone-9/10 Technique-6/10 Range-7/10 Performance-7/10 29/40
23. Alexis Grace: Tone- 7/10 Technique-7/10 Range-8/10 Performance-8/10 30/40
22. LaKisha Jones: Tone-7/10 Technique-6/10 Range-9/10 Performance- 8/10 30/40
21. Crystal Bowersox: Tone-8/10 Technique-7/10 Range-8/10 Performance-8/10 31/40
20. Nadia Turner: Tone-9/10 Technique-7/10 Range-6/10 Performance-10/10 32/40
19. Kimberley Locke: Tone-10/10 Technique-7/10 Range-7/10 Performance-8/10 32/40
18. Allison Iraheta: Tone-9/10 Technique-8/10 Range-8/10 Performance-7/10 32/40
17. Paris Bennett: Tone-8/10 Technique-8/10 Range-8/10 Performance-9/10 33/40
16. Syesha Mercado: Tone-7/10 Technique-8/10 Range-9/10 Performance-9/10 33/40
15. Diana DeGarmo: Tone-7/10 Technique-7/10 Range-10/10 Performance-9/10 33/40
14. Katharine McPhee: Tone- 8/10 Technique-8/10 Range-9/10 Performance-9/10 33/40
13. Trenyce: Tone-8/10 Technique-8/10 Range-9/10 Performance-10/10 35/40
12. Vonzell Solomon: Tone-8/10 Technique-8/10 Range-9/10 Performance-10/10 35/40
11. Melinda DooLittle: Tone-8/10 Technique-10/10 Range-8/10 Performance-9/10 35/40
10. Carly Smithson: Tone-8/10 Technique-10/10 Range-9/10 Performance-9/10 36/40
9. Pia Toscano: Tone-9/10 Technique-10/10 Range-10/10 Performance-7/10 36/40
8. Carrie Underwood: Tone-9/10 Technique-9/10 Range-9/10 Performance-9/10 36/40
7. LaToya London: Tone-9/10 Technique-9/10 Range-10/10 Performance-9/10 37/40
6. Fantasia Barrino: Tone-9/10 Technique-8/10 Range-10/10 Performance-10/10 37/40
5. Tamyra Gray: Tone-8/10 Technique-10/10 Range-10/10 Performance-10/10 38/40
4. Jordin Sparks: Tone-10/10 Technique-9/10 Range-10/10 Performance-9/10 38/40
3. Haley Reinhart: Tone-10/10 Technique-10/10 Range-9/10 Performance-9/10 38/40
2. Jennifer Hudson: Tone-10/10 Technique-10/10 Range-10/10 Performance-8/10 38/40
1. Kelly Clarkson: Tone-10/10 Technique- 9/10 Range- 10/10 Performance- 9/10 38/40